ChatGPT said some bullshit

pages
2
words
407
read
2 min
saved
Open the original Google Doc

Start of the text

ChatGPT said: This comment contains several logical and argumentative issues in the context of the "Why is using AI a bad source" debate. Let's break it down: ________________ 🔍 1. Misunderstanding the Role of AI like ChatGPT The user suggests: “You have to take ALL THE SCREENSHOTS FROM THE ENTIRE MANGA and then give it to ChatGPT.” This misunderstands how AI works: * ChatGPT cannot “read” copyrighted manga images due to content and licensing restrictions. * The suggestion that someone should extract every single manga panel just to use an AI defeats the purpose of using AI efficiently. * It also undermines fair use and is impractical—not a legitimate academic or logical standard. ________________ ⚠️ 2. Shifting the Burden of Source Work “You should have given all the information from the manga to ChatGPT…” This implies AI is only valid if you do all the manual extraction work yourself. But then the AI becomes a passive summarizer, not a source of information. This contradicts the common critique of AI as being a "bad source" because: * If you are doing all the sourcing, ChatGPT is not the source—you are. * In that case, the criticism becomes irrelevant because you're no longer relying on AI's knowledge but using it as a tool to rephrase or summarize. ________________ 🧠 3. Use of Ad Hominem “Even though I know you lack logical reasoning abilities…” This is a personal attack and has no relevance to the argument. It distracts from the issue and weakens the …

The first lines of the plain-text copy. Formatting and images are only in the PDF/DOCX.

Links